News Feed

Consent, not age, is real issue in early marriage, says report

www.thehindu.com
11 May 2015



“In a system that wishes to control female sexuality, acknowledging that girls can have sexual agency and desires is a threat”
 
There is more to the practice of early and child marriage than it being yet another ‘social evil’ waiting to be eradicated.
 
In its report, Early and Child Marriage in India: A Landscape Analysis, released here on Tuesday, the NGO Nirantar Trust shows that while the primary aim of most organisations working on the issue has been to address the problem of girls marrying before the legally permissible age of 18, an empowerment approach is what is needed to address the problem of lack of agency and choice among young people in influencing life-altering decisions. A blind emphasis on age becomes a distraction from the real problems of choice and consent with regards to marriage, the report notes.
 
According to the National Family Health Survey (2005-06), 74 per cent of women in India married before the age of 20. The report identifies seven root causes of early and child marriage: the economics of marriage, sexuality, gender norms and masculinity, educational and institutional gaps, the centrality of marriage, risk, vulnerability and uncertainty, and age as an axis of power.
 
Based on research in eight States where early marriage is widespread, the report shows how in a system that wishes to control female sexuality, acknowledging that girls can have sexual agency and desires is a threat. The anxiety caused by this is so strong that even conversations around contraception and safe sex are shameful and actively discouraged, lest they should give adolescents the “wrong idea.”
 
At the report’s launch, Lakshmi Sharma, Chief of Bureau, Khabar Lahariya newspaper in Lucknow, spoke about how marrying at the age of 14 had not stopped her from pursuing her interests, and there is life after marriage for women, thus emphasising the importance of women’s agency.
 
Guiding tool
Archana Dwivedi, Director, Nirantar Trust, said that similar to HIV/AIDS earlier, there was a great amount of interest and funding to work on the issue of early and child marriage in India, and the report was aimed at guiding organisations working in this area.
 
Statistics analysed in the report reveal the gendered nature of early and child marriage. The percentage of girls married before their legal age is the same as the percentage of boys married by 25. The report also notes that the difference between urban and rural statistics cannot be directly attributed to modernity and urbanisation. Often rural parents marry off their daughters in the village before they migrate so as to avoid the risks that young unwed girls face in cities.